Cheryl
August 7, 2001

First off, I have to say: Happy Birthday, Wayne! (and Happy Birthday yesterday to Beck and tomorrow to Jay and Meloney!)

Life has been busy as usual--my sister had another baby girl (Catherine Emily--known as Catie Bug), Mark started chemo and was dropped from the study (*sigh*), Alex and I have both been taking swimming (but she's learning the fun stuff like blowing bubbles in the water; I just get to swim from one side to the other for an hour). Oh, and about a month ago or so, I--in my "staff@elgonquin" guise--got an interesting email.

On June 29, out of the blue, I received a message from someone named TR Host. It read:

Attention Staff of Elgonquin:

The following URL contains both logos and copyrighted material taken from 
The Rules boards and The Rules Book website both of which are under 
copyright by Time.

http://www.elgonquin.com/archives/2000/03/18/Jennifer/

I would like to draw your attention to the following two paragraphs from 
Time Inc New Media's Rules of the Road found at  
http://www.pathfinder.com/help/hbb/rulesroad.html:

"Ownership of Messages. By posting messages on the bulletin boards, you are 
granting Time Inc. a royalty free, perpetual, non-exclusive and irrevocable 
right and license to use, reproduce, modify, adapt, publish, translate, 
create derivative works from, distribute, perform and display any posting by 
you (in whole or in part) worldwide and/or to incorporate it in other works 
in any form, media or technology now known or hereafter developed. "

"Proprietary Materials. You may not post or transmit any material of any 
nature, including, text, audio, software, animation or photographs, 
belonging to any person or party other than yourself, without the prior, 
written consent of such owner. Simply because material is available on the 
Internet does not mean it is in the public domain. The vast majority of 
materials on the Internet are protected by copyright and trademark laws. 
Also, the material available on Time Inc.'s sites, including the bulletin 
boards and chat areas are protected by copyright, owned either by Time Inc. 
or third party content providers and may not be disseminated by you without 
the consent of the copyright owner. You will be responsible for any damages 
resulting from any infringement of copyrights, trademarks, proprietary 
rights or any other harm resulting from your posting or transmission. "

Permission was neither requested nor granted.  Please remove this material 
immediately.

Thank you,

Sloe
The Rules Host for Time Inc. New Media

cc: the user who brought this to my attention
Yeesh. What had we done to piss off Time, Inc.?

Fortunately, at about the same time, I also got another email out of the blue--this one by someone who's calling herself liatris here (Liatris is the botanical name for a flower I had in plant ID this spring--cool!). Liatris is a long-time participant on the bulletin boards Time runs in connection with the The Rules books (which are published by Time). There she tends to play a devil's advocate role at times, and this was one of the times where she wanted to make sure I got a fuller story than what I'd get from TR Host. Apparently, someone had just stumbled across Jennifer's set of posts from a year ago in March, where she used text from the bulletin boards to corroborate her opinions about The Rules and the women who followed them. That someone was not amused by Jennifer's conclusions, and particularly not amused that Jennifer quoted members of the bulletin board. (Liatris suspects, and I agree, that were Jennifer's entries flattering to The Rules, nobody would have suggested that she infringed on their copyright.)

The emails started flying between me, Jennifer, and Harry. Any guesses what Harry's position was? How about Jennifer's?

More on this in a couple of days.

Cheryl
laste-mailnext


The ElgonquinJoin the Round TableCheck out past Lunch DatesFind out more at the Reference Desk


©1999-2001 ELGONQUIN.COM. Content of individual entries ©1999-2001 by the respective authors.